There’s something magical about combining classic flavors with a modern twist, and our S’mores Old Fashioned recipe does just that. Inspired by the nostalgic campfire treat, this cocktail blends the rich, smoky notes of an Old Fashioned with the sweet, gooey goodness of s’mores. It’s the perfect way to elevate your cocktail game while indulging in a beloved dessert flavor.
Whether you’re hosting a cozy gathering or just want to treat yourself, this drink brings warmth and comfort in every sip. We’ll guide you through crafting this unique cocktail that’s sure to impress both whiskey lovers and sweet tooths alike. Get ready to enjoy a drink that’s equal parts classic and creative.
Ingredients
To craft the perfect S’mores Old Fashioned, we carefully select each ingredient to capture the nostalgic essence of s’mores while enhancing the classic Old Fashioned profile. Here is the list of ingredients you will need:
- 2 oz bourbon whiskey — the rich base for our drink.
- 1/2 oz marshmallow syrup — infuses the cocktail with that characteristic toasted marshmallow sweetness.
- 1/4 oz chocolate liqueur — adds a smooth, decadent chocolate layer.
- 2 dashes of Angostura bitters — balance the sweetness with aromatic complexity.
- 1 sugar cube — for muddling and subtle sweetness.
- Orange twist — to garnish, lending bright citrus notes.
- Toasted marshmallow — classic s’mores garnish, adds visual appeal and extra flavor.
Ingredient Details
| Ingredient | Quantity | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Bourbon Whiskey | 2 oz | Base spirit rich in flavor |
| Marshmallow Syrup | 1/2 oz | Adds sweetness and marshmallow aroma |
| Chocolate Liqueur | 1/4 oz | Infuses chocolate flavor |
| Angostura Bitters | 2 dashes | Adds depth and balance |
| Sugar Cube | 1 | Sweetener for muddling |
| Orange Twist | 1 | Garnish for bright citrus note |
| Toasted Marshmallow | 1 | Classic s’mores touch garnish |
We recommend using real marshmallows toasted over a flame to garnish for that authentic campfire aroma and visual delight. The marshmallow syrup can be homemade or store-bought, but be sure it is rich and not overly sweet to complement the whiskey’s warmth perfectly.
This carefully curated combination of ingredients brings together the familiar warmth of an Old Fashioned with the comforting nostalgia of s’mores—resulting in a drink that is both impressive and indulgent.
Equipment Needed
To craft the perfect S’mores Old Fashioned, having the right equipment is essential. Each tool plays a role in ensuring our cocktail has the ideal flavor balance, presentation, and texture. Here’s what we need to bring this nostalgic drink to life:
- Old Fashioned Glass
This classic short tumbler showcases the cocktail beautifully and provides the perfect vessel for muddling and stirring. Its wide rim also allows for adding garnishes like the orange twist and toasted marshmallow.
- Mixing Glass or Shaker
We use a mixing glass to properly stir the ingredients with ice, chilling the drink without over-diluting. A shaker is unnecessary here, as shaking can dilute the whiskey’s richness.
- Bar Spoon
The long handle of a bar spoon helps us nicely stir the drink to blend the bourbon, marshmallow syrup, chocolate liqueur, bitters, and sugar cube evenly.
- Muddler
Essential for dissolving the sugar cube with bitters to release deep, aromatic flavors—this step forms the base of our Old Fashioned.
- Jigger
Precise measurements are crucial. With a jigger, we measure 2 oz of bourbon, 1/2 oz of marshmallow syrup, and 1/4 oz of chocolate liqueur with accuracy.
- Citrus Peeler or Paring Knife
To create the perfect orange twist garnish, this tool helps us peel a thin strip of orange zest without the bitter white pith.
- Kitchen Torch or Roasting Skewer
For authentic toasted marshmallows, a kitchen torch gives us control over the caramelization. Alternatively, a roasting skewer lets us toast marshmallows over an open flame for that nostalgic touch.
Equipment Summary Table
| Equipment | Purpose | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Old Fashioned Glass | Serving vessel, garnish holder | Use a sturdy glass for best experience |
| Mixing Glass | Stirring ingredients with ice | Avoid shaking to maintain texture |
| Bar Spoon | Even mixing | Long handle for easy stirring |
| Muddler | Dissolve sugar cube with bitters | Essential for base flavor |
| Jigger | Measuring liquid ingredients | Ensures consistent flavor balance |
| Citrus Peeler/Knife | Creating orange twist garnish | Avoid pith for smooth citrus aroma |
| Kitchen Torch/Skewer | Toasting marshmallows | Torch for control, skewer for authenticity |
By assembling these key tools, we set ourselves up for success in preparing a rich, luxurious S’mores Old Fashioned that delivers on both flavor and presentation. Let’s gather our equipment and move confidently into the mixing process.
Prep Work
Before mixing our S’mores Old Fashioned, we focus on prep work that elevates the cocktail’s flavor and presentation. Proper preparation ensures each component shines, especially the signature toasted marshmallow elements.
Preparing the Marshmallow Rim
To create the perfect marshmallow rim that complements the drink’s rich profile:
- Step 1: Lightly moisten the rim of an Old Fashioned glass using a fresh orange twist or a small amount of water. This helps the marshmallow sugar adhere evenly.
- Step 2: Spread marshmallow sugar (or superfine sugar mixed with finely crushed marshmallow bits) on a shallow plate.
- Step 3: Gently roll or dip the glass rim into the marshmallow sugar mixture until fully coated.
- Step 4: Let the rim dry for 2 minutes so the sugar sets but remains sticky enough to enhance every sip.
This method creates a sweet, slightly crunchy rim that melds perfectly with the cocktail’s warmth and sweetness, adding a delightful tactile sensation.
Toasting the Marshmallows
Our cocktail’s crowning glory is the toasted marshmallow garnish. Here’s how to achieve the ideal crisp exterior with a molten center:
| Step | Action | Details | Tools Needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Skewer the marshmallow | Choose large, fresh marshmallows | Roasting skewer or metal pick |
| 2 | Heat the marshmallow | Use a kitchen torch or open flame carefully | Kitchen torch or gas flame |
| 3 | Toast evenly | Rotate slowly for golden brown, avoid burning | N/A |
| 4 | Rest before garnishing | Allow a 15-second rest for caramelization to settle | N/A |
“The goal is a perfectly caramelized, golden marshmallow that adds smoky sweetness and visual appeal.” The toasted marshmallow melts slightly into the drink’s aromatic swirl, fully capturing the essence of a classic campfire s’more.
By mastering these prep steps, we set the foundation for the ultimate S’mores Old Fashioned experience—indulgent, nostalgic, and beautifully balanced.
Directions
Let’s craft the perfect S’mores Old Fashioned step-by-step to capture that rich nostalgic flavor with every sip.
Making the S’Mores Old Fashioned Cocktail
- Prepare your glass by moistening the rim and dipping it in marshmallow sugar to create a sweet, textured edge. Let it dry to set.
- Add the sugar cube to a mixing glass. Pour 2 dashes of Angostura bitters over it.
- Muddle the sugar cube and bitters gently until the sugar dissolves, creating a smooth bitters-infused syrup base.
- Using a jigger, measure and pour in 2 oz bourbon whiskey to the mixing glass.
- Add 1/2 oz marshmallow syrup and 1/4 oz chocolate liqueur to the mixture for that signature s’mores sweetness and depth.
- Fill the mixing glass with ice cubes and stir with a bar spoon for about 30 seconds until well chilled and properly diluted.
- Strain the cocktail into the prepared Old Fashioned glass over a large ice cube to keep the drink cold without quick dilution.
Garnishing and Serving
- Use a citrus peeler or paring knife to create a fresh orange twist. Express the oils over the surface of the drink to enhance aroma.
- Rub the orange twist along the rim for subtle citrus notes.
- Skewer a perfectly toasted marshmallow (caramelized golden-brown with a molten center) and place it atop the glass as a garnish.
- Serve immediately and enjoy the harmonious blend of whiskey warmth, toasted marshmallow sweetness, and chocolate richness.
| Step | Task | Key Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Glass preparation | Rim with marshmallow sugar | Let dry for perfect coating |
| Muddling | Sugar cube + bitters | Dissolve completely |
| Measuring & mixing | Bourbon + syrups + ice | Stir 30 seconds |
| Serving | Strain into glass over large ice | Keeps cocktail cold longer |
| Garnishing | Orange twist + toasted marshmallow | Adds aroma and visual appeal |
Tips for the Perfect S’Mores Old Fashioned
To master the art of crafting the perfect S’Mores Old Fashioned, we should focus on precise techniques and quality ingredients that elevate every sip. Here are our top tips to achieve that rich, nostalgic flavor while maintaining balance and presentation:
Use Quality Bourbon for a Smooth Base
Choose a well-aged bourbon with rich caramel and vanilla notes. This enhances the dessert-inspired elements without overpowering the drink. Avoid overly harsh or spicy bourbons that can clash with the sweetness.
Balance Sweetness Carefully
The marshmallow syrup and chocolate liqueur add sweetness, but too much can mask the bourbon’s warmth. Start by adding the recommended amounts, then adjust slightly if needed. Remember, balance is key.
Perfect the Marshmallow Rim
- Moisten the glass rim lightly with water or simple syrup to ensure the marshmallow sugar adheres well.
- Use a fine marshmallow sugar or finely crushed toasted marshmallows for an even coating.
- Allow the rim to dry for a few minutes before pouring the cocktail to prevent sogginess.
Toast Marshmallows with Precision
Achieving a perfectly toasted marshmallow garnish requires patience:
- Use a kitchen torch or roasting skewer and rotate slowly to get an even golden crust.
- Aim for a caramelized exterior with a gooey, molten center to complement the drink’s texture and aroma.
Stir, Don’t Shake
We want to maintain clarity and smoothness in the S’Mores Old Fashioned. Stirring with ice chills and dilutes the drink perfectly. Use a bar spoon and stir gently for about 20 seconds.
Use Large Ice Cubes
A single large ice cube melts slower than smaller ones, keeping the drink chilled without over-dilution. This preserves the cocktail’s intended flavor balance longer.
Fresh Orange Twist Garnish
Peel a fresh orange to release essential oils. Twist the peel over the glass to spray citrus aroma atop the cocktail. This adds brightness that complements the rich s’mores notes.
Ingredient & Preparation Summary Table
| Component | Tip | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Bourbon | Choose smooth, well-aged | Adds depth and warmth |
| Marshmallow Syrup | Use in moderation | Sweetness with nostalgic flavor |
| Chocolate Liqueur | Measure precisely | Adds rich cocoa notes |
| Marshmallow Sugar Rim | Use fine sugar, moisten rim | Enhances texture and visual appeal |
| Toasted Marshmallow | Even golden crust, molten center | Adds aroma and smoky sweetness |
| Ice Cube | Use large cube | Controls dilution and maintains chill |
| Orange Twist | Twist over glass releasing oils | Balances sweetness with citrus brightness |
By following these expert tips we ensure every S’Mores Old Fashioned we create delivers that warm, indulgent experience with exceptional flavor and style.
Variations to Try
Exploring variations of the S’mores Old Fashioned allows us to customize this nostalgic cocktail to suit different palates and occasions. Here are some creative twists that maintain the core flavors while adding exciting new dimensions.
1. Spiced S’mores Old Fashioned
Add warmth and complexity by incorporating spices:
- Use a cinnamon-infused bourbon or add a cinnamon stick as a garnish
- Include 2 dashes of aromatic bitters like clove or cardamom bitters in place of or alongside Angostura bitters
- Substitute marshmallow syrup with a spiced marshmallow syrup infused with nutmeg and star anise
2. Smoky Campfire S’mores
To replicate an authentic campfire experience:
- Use a smoky bourbon or add a splash of mezcal for smoky notes
- Toast the marshmallow with a heavier char for intensified smokiness
- Garnish with a small cinnamon stick or toasted pine needles for aroma
3. Chocolate Lover’s S’mores Old Fashioned
Elevate the chocolate component:
- Increase chocolate liqueur to 1/2 oz for richer chocolate flavor
- Rim the glass with chocolate shavings mixed with marshmallow sugar
- Garnish with a piece of dark chocolate alongside the toasted marshmallow
4. Nutty S’mores Twist
Add a nutty crunch and flavor depth:
- Use hazelnut or almond liqueur in place of or alongside chocolate liqueur
- Garnish with crushed roasted nuts on the glass rim or sprinkled on top
- Use a nut butter-rimmed glass (lightly coat rim with nut butter, then dip in marshmallow sugar)
5. Citrus-Infused S’mores Old Fashioned
Brighten the cocktail with citrus:
- Add a splash (1/4 oz) of orange or blood orange liqueur
- Use an orange zest twist plus a lemon peel for garnish
- Infuse the marshmallow syrup with citrus peel during preparation
| Variation | Key Flavor Additions | Garnish Ideas | Syrup/Liqueur Modifications |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spiced S’mores | Cinnamon, clove, cardamom | Cinnamon stick | Spiced marshmallow syrup |
| Smoky Campfire | Mezcal, smoky bourbon, charred marshmallow | Toasted pine needles, cinnamon stick | Original syrup |
| Chocolate Lover’s | Extra chocolate liqueur | Dark chocolate, chocolate shavings | Increase chocolate liqueur |
| Nutty Twist | Nut liqueur (hazelnut/almond) | Roasted nuts, nut butter rim | Nut liqueur |
| Citrus-Infused | Orange/blood orange liqueur | Orange zest, lemon peel | Citrus-infused marshmallow syrup |
Tips for Trying Variations
- Always taste as you build to maintain the balance between sweetness, bitterness, and warmth.
- Adjust the amount of marshmallow syrup accordingly to prevent overpowering sweetness.
- Refresh the marshmallow rim if garnish flavors change drastically to keep presentation consistent.
“Crafting a personalized S’mores Old Fashioned is about embracing the playful spirit of cocktails while honoring the comforting nostalgia of s’mores.”
By experimenting with these variations, we elevate your cocktail experience, ensuring each sip tells a delicious story tailored to your taste.
Make-Ahead Instructions
To ensure our S’mores Old Fashioned dazzles every time, proper make-ahead preparation is essential. By prepping key components in advance, we save time and maintain consistent quality for gatherings or a quiet evening treat.
Prepare the Marshmallow Syrup
- Combine granulated sugar, water, and marshmallow fluff in a saucepan over medium heat.
- Stir continuously until fully dissolved and smooth.
- Let the syrup cool completely before bottling in an airtight container.
- Store in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks.
Toast Marshmallows Ahead of Time
- Using a kitchen torch or roasting skewer, toast marshmallows until golden brown with a slightly caramelized crust.
- Place toasted marshmallows on a parchment-lined tray to cool.
- Store loosely covered at room temperature for up to 24 hours to maintain texture.
Marshmallow Rim Preparation
- Moistening the rims of glasses and coating them with marshmallow sugar can be done several hours before serving.
- Allow rims to dry completely to avoid dilution when the drink is poured.
- Keep prepared glasses covered upside down to protect from dust and debris.
| Make-Ahead Step | Storage | Shelf Life | Tips for Best Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marshmallow Syrup | Airtight jar in refrigerator | Up to 2 weeks | Stir before use if sugar settles |
| Toasted Marshmallows | Loosely covered at room temp | Up to 24 hours | Use within a day to retain perfect toasted texture |
| Marshmallow Rimmed Glass | Covered upside down | Several hours before | Prepare just before an event for crisp texture |
“Preparing these elements ahead ensures every S’mores Old Fashioned impresses with rich, balanced flavors and impeccable presentation.“
By planning ahead, we can focus on the final assembly and garnishing, elevating the cocktail experience with ease and confidence.
Conclusion
Crafting the S’mores Old Fashioned is a rewarding way to blend classic cocktail tradition with nostalgic flavors. With the right ingredients, tools, and techniques, we can create a drink that’s both comforting and impressive. Whether we stick to the classic recipe or explore variations, this cocktail invites creativity and warmth in every sip.
Taking the time to prepare key components ahead ensures a smooth and enjoyable experience when entertaining or relaxing. The S’mores Old Fashioned isn’t just a drink—it’s a celebration of flavor and craftsmanship that elevates any occasion.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a S’mores Old Fashioned?
A S’mores Old Fashioned is a creative cocktail that blends the classic Old Fashioned’s bourbon base with flavors of marshmallow, chocolate, and bitters, inspired by the nostalgic taste of s’mores.
What ingredients are needed for a S’mores Old Fashioned?
You need bourbon whiskey, marshmallow syrup, chocolate liqueur, Angostura bitters, a sugar cube, an orange twist, and a toasted marshmallow for garnish.
How do I make marshmallow syrup for the cocktail?
Marshmallow syrup is typically made by dissolving sugar in water and mixing it with melted marshmallows or marshmallow flavoring until smooth and thick but not overly sweet.
Can I use any bourbon for the S’mores Old Fashioned?
It’s best to use a well-aged bourbon because it provides a smooth, rich base that balances well with the sweetness and flavors of the marshmallow and chocolate.
What tools do I need to prepare the S’mores Old Fashioned?
Essential tools include an Old Fashioned glass, mixing glass, bar spoon, muddler, jigger, citrus peeler, and a kitchen torch or skewer for toasting marshmallows.
How do I create the marshmallow rim?
Moisten the glass rim, dip it into marshmallow sugar, then let it dry to add a sweet, textured edge that complements the drink’s flavors.
What’s the best way to toast marshmallows for this cocktail?
Toast marshmallows evenly using a kitchen torch or skewer until they have a caramelized, golden exterior and a molten center for smoky sweetness.
Should I shake or stir the S’mores Old Fashioned?
Stirring is preferred to gently mix ingredients and chill the drink without bruising the bourbon or diluting flavors too quickly.
Are there any variations of the S’mores Old Fashioned?
Yes, variations include adding spices, smoky flavors, extra chocolate, nuts, or citrus to suit different tastes and occasions.
How can I prepare parts of the cocktail ahead of time?
Make the marshmallow syrup, toast marshmallows, and create the marshmallow rim in advance, storing them properly for freshness to streamline assembly when ready to serve.